ORCID Profile
0000-0003-1222-1583
Current Organisations
The University of Edinburgh
,
University of Oxford
,
Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule Zürich
Does something not look right? The information on this page has been harvested from data sources that may not be up to date. We continue to work with information providers to improve coverage and quality. To report an issue, use the Feedback Form.
Publisher: Copernicus GmbH
Date: 04-03-2021
DOI: 10.5194/EGUSPHERE-EGU21-9048
Abstract: & & The localisation of structural damage, in the form of faults and fractures, along a distinct and emergent fault plane is the key driving mechanism for catastrophic failure in the brittle Earth. However, due to the speed at which stable crack growth transitions to dynamic rupture, the precise mechanisms involved in localisation as a pathway to fault formation remain unknown. Understanding these mechanisms is critical to understanding and forecasting earthquakes, including induced seismicity, landslides and volcanic eruptions, as well as failure of man-made materials and structures. We used time-resolved synchrotron x-ray microtomography to image in-situ damage localisation at the micron scale and at bulk axial strain rates down to 10& sup& -7& /sup& s& sup& -1& /sup& . By controlling the rate of micro-fracturing events during a triaxial deformation experiment, we deliberately slowed the strain localisation process from seconds to minutes as failure approached. This approach, originally established to indirectly image fault nucleation and propagation with acoustic emissions, is completely novel in synchrotron x-ray microtomography and has enabled us to image directly processes that are normally too transient even for fast synchrotron imaging methods. Here, we first present the experimental apparatus and control system used to acquire the data, followed by damage localisation and shear zone development in a s le of Clashach sandstone viewed in unprecedented detail. Time-resolved microtomography images demonstrate a strong intrinsic correlation between shear and dilatant strain in the localised zone, with bulk shear strain accomodated by the nucleation and rotation of en-echelon tensile microcracks within a grain-scale shear band. Rotation is accompanied by antithetic to synthetic shear sliding of neighbouring crack surfaces as they rotate. The evolving 4D strain field, measured with incremental digital volume correlation between pairs of recorded x-ray tomographic volumes, independently confirm the correlation between shear and dilatant strain and show how strain localises spontaneously, first through exploration of several competing shear bands at peak stress before transitioning to failure along the optimally-oriented final fault plane. In order to & #8216 ground-truth& #8217 inferences made from bulk measurements and seismic waves (the primary method of detecting deformation at the field-scale where direct imaging of the subsurface is impossible), we (a) compare rupture energy estimates from local slip measurements with those from bulk slip data, and (b) use AE source location estimates to identify in idual cracks and other local changes in the microstucture that may explain the AE source.& &
Publisher: Copernicus GmbH
Date: 27-03-2022
DOI: 10.5194/EGUSPHERE-EGU22-5818
Abstract: & & Catastrophic failure in brittle, porous materials initiates when structural damage, in the form of smaller-scale fractures, localises along an emergent failure plane or 'fault' in a transition from stable crack growth to dynamic rupture. Due to the extremely rapid nature of this critical transition, the precise micro-mechanisms involved are poorly understood and difficult to capture. However, these mechanisms are crucial drivers for devastating phenomena such as earthquakes, including induced seismicity, landslides and volcanic eruptions, as well as large-scale infrastructure collapse. Here we observe these micro-mechanisms directly by controlling the rate of micro-fracturing events to slow down the transition in a unique triaxial deformation experiment that combines acoustic monitoring with contemporaneous & em& in-situ& /em& x-ray imaging of the microstructure. The results provide the first integrated picture of how damage and associated micro-seismic events emerge and evolve together during localisation and failure and allow us to ground truth some previous inferences from mechanical and seismic monitoring alone. They also highlight where such inferences miss important kinematically-governed grain-scale mechanisms prior to and during shear failure.& & & & The evolving damage imaged in the 3D x-ray volumes and local strain fields undergoes a breakdown sequence involving several stages: (i) self-organised exploration of candidate shear zones close to peak stress, (ii) spontaneous tensile failure of in idual grains due to point loading and pore-emanating fractures within an emergent and localised shear zone, validating many inferences from acoustic emissions monitoring, and (iii) formation of a proto-cataclasite due to grain rotation and fragmentation, highlighting both the control of grain size on failure and the relative importance of aseismic mechanisms such as crack rotation in accommodating bulk shear deformation. Dilation and shear strain remain strongly correlated both spatially and temporally throughout s le weakening, confirming the existence of a cohesive zone, but with crack damage distributed throughout the shear zone rather than concentrated solely in a breakdown zone at the propagating front of a pre-existing discontinuity.& & & & Contrary to common assumption, we find seismic litude is not correlated with local imaged strain large local strain often occurs with small acoustic emissions, and vice versa. The seismic strain partition coefficient is very low overall and locally highly variable. Local strain is therefore predominantly aseismic, explained in part by grain/crack rotation along the emergent shear zone. The shear fracture energy calculated from local dilation and shear strain on the fault is half of that inferred from the bulk deformation, with a smaller critical slip distance, indicating that less energy is required for local breakdown in the shear zone compared with models of uniform slip.& & & & This improvement in process-based understanding holds out the prospect of reducing systematic errors in forecasting system-sized catastrophic failure in a variety of applications.& &
Publisher: Copernicus GmbH
Date: 04-03-2021
DOI: 10.5194/EGUSPHERE-EGU21-15691
Abstract: & & Catastrophic failure is a critical phenomenon present in Earth systems on a variety of scales, and is associated with the evolution of damage leading to system-size failure. Laboratory testing of rock failure permits characterization of fracture network evolution at the micro-scale to understand the interaction of cracks, pores and grain boundaries to an applied stress field, and the relationship between deformation and seismic response. Previous studies have relied on acoustic emissions (hearing) or X-ray imaging (seeing) to study the process of localization, which involves spontaneous self-organization of smaller cracks along faults and fractures on localised zones of deformation. To combine hearing and seeing of the microscopic processes and their control of system-sized failure, a novel x-ray transparent cell was used for deformation experiments of rock s les, which permits integration of acoustic monitoring with fast synchrotron x-ray imaging. To increase temporal characterization of damage beyond the temporal resolution of the fast 3D synchrotron system, acoustic emission (AE) feedback control was used to regulate the applied stress and slow down the deformation processes. As a result, there is increased temporal resolution of the incremental deformation between successive x-ray scanned states allowing synchronized comparison of acoustic emissions to x-ray scans. Here, we present the seismic analysis used to characterize the velocity evolution of the rock s les, and the location and characteristics of in idual AE events in relation to microscopic deformation processes. Time-lapse velocity measurements are linked to internal stress changes and structural damage corresponding to seismic and aseismic deformation processes, while acoustic emissions are a direct indication of local cracking.& We show that we can successfully locate AE events in 3D using only two sensors on either end of the s le, based on ellipsoid mapping, and x-ray image to event correlation. We explore temporal and spatial statistics of AE signatures and how those are linked to the strain field in the s les measured with incremental digital volume correlation between pairs of recorded x-ray tomograms. The direct observation of AE and X-ray images enables quantification of relevant seismic (local cracking leading to AE) to aseismic (elastic loading and silent irreversible damage) processes, with information extracted over fine temporal resolution throughout the deformation process through the AE-feedback control.& &
Publisher: Copernicus GmbH
Date: 15-05-2023
DOI: 10.5194/EGUSPHERE-EGU23-7933
Abstract: Catastrophic failure in brittle, porous materials initiates when structural damage, in the form of smaller-scale fractures, localises along an emergent failure plane or 'fault' in a transition from stable crack growth to dynamic rupture. Due to the extremely rapid nature of this critical transition, the precise micro-mechanisms involved are poorly understood and difficult to capture. However, these mechanisms are crucial drivers for devastating phenomena such as earthquakes, including induced seismicity, landslides and volcanic eruptions, as well as large-scale infrastructure collapse. Here we observe these micro-mechanisms directly by controlling the rate of micro-fracturing events to slow down the transition in a unique triaxial deformation experiment that combines acoustic monitoring with contemporaneous in-situ x-ray imaging of the microstructure. The results [1] provide the first integrated picture of how damage and associated micro-seismic events emerge and evolve together during localisation and failure and allow us to ground truth some previous inferences from mechanical and seismic monitoring alone. They also highlight where such inferences miss important kinematically-governed grain-scale mechanisms prior to and during shear failure.The evolving damage imaged in the 3D x-ray volumes and local strain fields undergoes a breakdown sequence involving several stages: (i) self-organised exploration of candidate shear zones close to peak stress, (ii) spontaneous tensile failure of in idual grains due to point loading and pore-emanating fractures within an emergent and localised shear zone, validating many inferences from acoustic emissions monitoring, (iii) formation of a proto-cataclasite due to grain rotation and fragmentation, highlighting both the control of grain size on failure and the relative importance of aseismic mechanisms such as crack rotation in accommodating bulk shear deformation. Dilation and shear strain remain strongly correlated both spatially and temporally throughout s le weakening, confirming the existence of a cohesive zone, but with crack damage distributed throughout the shear zone rather than concentrated solely in a breakdown zone at the propagating front of a pre-existing discontinuity.Contrary to common assumption, we find seismic litude is not correlated with local imaged strain large local strain often occurs with small acoustic emissions, and vice versa. The seismic strain partition coefficient is very low overall and locally highly variable. Local strain is therefore predominantly aseismic, explained in part by grain/crack rotation along the emergent shear zone. The shear fracture energy calculated from local dilation and shear strain on the fault is half of that inferred from the bulk deformation, with a smaller critical slip distance, indicating that less energy is required for local breakdown in the shear zone compared with models of uniform slip.This improvement in process-based understanding holds out the prospect of reducing systematic errors in forecasting system-sized catastrophic failure in a variety of applications.[1] Cartwright-Taylor et al. 2022, Nature Communications 13, 6169, 0.1038/s41467-022-33855-z
Location: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Location: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Location: United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
No related grants have been discovered for Andrew Curtis.